Papa Angelo's Pizzeria

4.5 ( 861 reviews )
Checking... 11:00 AM - 9:00 PM See Hours
$10–20
6744 NW 39th Expy, Bethany, OK 73008, United States
+1 405-491-6767
Papa Angelo's Pizzeria, nestled in Bethany, Oklahoma, is the go-to destination for authentic New York-style pizza lovers. Diners praise the incredibly fresh and flavorful offerings, with glowing reviews highlighting the Empire-size pizza and irresistible garlic knots. The ambience serves as a delightful nod to NYC, making your dining experience more enjoyable while you await your meal, surrounded by a vibrant history. Patrons rave about the versatility of the menu, which features not just pizza but also delectable pasta dishes like baked ziti, creative salads, and tempting desserts such as cannoli and cheesecake slices. Standout mentions include the homemade Reaper sauce that adds just the right amount of spice to dishes. Many guests have even found themselves returning multiple days in a row due to the quality and delightful flavors. Customers emphasize the exceptional service; friendly staff enhance the overall experience, making it evident that this pizzeria has a dedicated aim to provide satisfaction. With options for customization and a lively atmosphere, it's easy to understand why locals like Mike and Kira rave about Papa Angelo's as one of the best pizza spots in OKC. Whether you come for a casual bite or a late-night craving, Papa Angelo's Pizzeria is sure to impress.

Amenities and More

  • Accessibility
    • Has wheelchair-accessible car park
    • Has wheelchair-accessible entrance
    • Has wheelchair-accessible seating
    • Has wheelchair-accessible toilet
  • Service options
    • Offers delivery
    • Offers takeaway
    • Serves dine-in
  • Highlights
    • Has fast service
    • Good for watching sport
  • Popular for
    • Popular for lunch
    • Popular for dinner
    • Good for solo dining
  • Offerings
    • Serves alcohol
    • Serves beer
    • Serves comfort food
    • Quick bite
    • Serves vegetarian dishes
  • Dining options
    • Serves lunch
    • Serves dinner
    • Has catering
    • Has counter service
    • Serves dessert
    • Has seating
  • Amenities
    • Has toilet
  • Atmosphere
    • Casual
    • Cosy
    • Trendy
  • Crowd
    • Family friendly
    • Good for groups
    • Popular with tourists
    • Popular with university students
  • Planning
    • Doesn't accept reservations
  • Payments
    • Accepts credit cards
    • Accepts debit cards
    • Credit cards
  • Children
    • Good for kids
    • High chairs available
  • Parking
    • Free of charge street parking
    • Free parking lot
    • Plenty of parking

Reviews For Papa Angelo's Pizzeria

Chris Zuraff
May 30,2025
A treat!! Authentic big new Yorker pies from Authentic New yorkers. Chose from their selection or create your own. Good hot or for late cravings. And don't forget to check out all the history on the walls while you wait
Patrick H
May 23,2025
Staff was friendly food was delicious highly recommend the empire size pizza and the delicious garlic knots , we went here for cannolis but unfortunately they were out so we got cheesecake , but all was still really good . I recommend everyone to come here!!
Flip Out
May 21,2025
If you’re looking for New York style pizza, look no further than Papa Angelo’s. We always enjoy what we order; the food is always very fresh and delicious. The atmosphere is a fun tribute to NYC.
Mike Knebel
May 8,2025
My favorite Pizza in OKC (located in Bethany)! We dropped by and ordered a couple pizzas on Sunday. They were so good, we went back on Monday! Thanks Joe (owner) and Dianna (sp?) (owner)! The garlic knots are a must! As a bonus, Papa Angelo's serves beer from my favorite local brewery, Broke Brewing! I don't normally choose Canadian Bacon, but it's my first choice here, with their special jalapenos!
Kira Yagami
Mar 16,2025
Best pizza in OKC! The food, service, and environment is excellent! I had a meatball & black olive pizza with their homemade Reaper sauce. By far the best spicy pizza I’ve ever had. It was the real deal. The flavor was amazing and the heat had me sweating like crazy.
Ron C
Mar 15,2025
This place is so cool. Being from Ling Island the inside looks like you’ve stepped into another part of the country...not Bethany Oklahoma. The decor, the smell, it’s very NY authentic. The flavors of the pizza are great. We’ve been coming here for years. The difference I saw in this visit was the sausage. They used to use more of a sliced sausage...like pepperoni. Now it’s sausage crumbles. Still tasted good I just really like the old sausage better. Couldn’t get that anywhere around here.
L Hardman
Feb 21,2025
The pizza was so good. It was like having a New Yorker pizza. The atmosphere is wonderful it makes you wanna stay and hang out. A day that I went they have music playing and Peggy Johnson. It was wonderful. They came and checked on us periodically to make sure that we did not need anything. That’s definitely a place that I will return to eat.
sun Neth
Feb 13,2025
Great Peppi pizza. Its folds with all the oils dripping just like a new style should be. The baked ziti was nice. The sauce wasn’t overly sweet like others

Add a Review

Quality
Location
Price
Space
Service

Location

Appreciated by Others

Akash Tandoori
(110 review)
Akash Tandoori
  • 219 High Rd, South Benfleet, Benfleet SS7 5HZ, United Kingdom
Indian restaurant
+44 1268 566238
Plas yn Dinas
(221 review)
Plas yn Dinas
  • Maes Mechain, Llanfechain SY22 6UL, United Kingdom
Bar & grill
+44 1691 828549
Las Ramblas Wine & Tapas
(950 review)
Las Ramblas Wine & Tapas
  • Treasury Building, Basement 1, Palmyra Square South, Warrington WA1 1BL, United Kingdom
Tapas restaurant
+44 1925 654199
Fiesta Guadalajara
(955 review)
Fiesta Guadalajara
  • 1202 N Jacob Alcott Way, Nampa, ID 83687, United States
mexican restaurant
+1 208-467-1548
CLUTCH Coffee Bar
(426 review)
CLUTCH Coffee Bar
  • 2432 Lewisville Clemmons Rd, Clemmons, NC 27012, United States
Coffee shop
Smoked BBQ
(597 review)
Smoked BBQ
  • 1801 N Roosevelt Blvd, Key West, FL 33040, United States
Barbecue restaurant
+1 305-741-7409
Sushi & Galbi
(601 review)
Sushi & Galbi
  • 1519 Highland Ave, National City, CA 91950, United States
Sushi restaurant
+1 619-434-4154
Sabaidee Lao & Thai Street Food - Addison
(673 review)
Sabaidee Lao & Thai Street Food - Addison
  • 5365 Spring Valley Rd STE 158, Dallas, TX 75254, United States
Thai restaurant
+1 972-863-7575
Ispahan
(279 review)
Ispahan
  • 1777 Centre St, Montreal, Quebec H3K 1H8, Canada
persian restaurant
+1 514-805-5002
The Juicy Crab Austell
(3625 review)
The Juicy Crab Austell
  • 1345 East-West Connector, Austell, GA 30106, United States
Seafood restaurant
+1 678-741-7980